Civilian marksmanship was appalling, for a population obsessed with guns.
– Jack Reacher
Lee Child (pen name for author Jim Grant) is the creator of the Jack Reacher series of novels, which inspired the Hollywood movie of the same name.
I can appreciate Reacher/Child/Grant’s sentiment, but I’d drop the civilian descriptor as military marksmanship can be frightfully poor as well.
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter for more reviews.
Reacher is a claimed winner of the Wimbledon Cup, described as “the only non-Marine to win the U.S. Marine Corps 1000 Yard Invitational rifle competition.”
In reality, The Wimbledon Cup is an open civilian match and is but a part of the NRA Long Range Championships. All the trophies and events of the NRA Long Range Championships are described here:
http://competitions.nra.org/nra-national-trophies.aspx#hplr
Why is it incorrectly thought to be a Marine match? And why the fixation on one single match instead of the overall aggregate? Probably because Carlos Hathcock won it back in 1965 with a score of 100-17V (yes, this was before the smaller, more difficult decimal target was adopted.) Hathcock’s later exploits in Viet Nam as a Marine sniper garnered him some fame.
Point of Impact by Stephen Hunter revolves around a former Vietnam War sniper named Bob Lee Swagger. The book was later made into the film Shooter with “Marky Mark” Wahlberg playing Swagger. Says Hunter,
I wanted to write a novel about a sniper. I’d read a biography of Carlos Hathcock, a Marine sniper. … Carlos Hathcock lost a spotter in Vietnam. So, I had Bob lose a spotter in Vietnam. Of course, the movie has been updated, so Vietnam hasn’t figured in it.
What the sniper fanboys, wannabes and novelists seem to forget is that modern sniping doctrine was created by competition shooters.
In September 1966 Captain Jim Land arrived in Vietnam. He had come specifically to train and organize Scout/Snipers for the First Marine Division which would soon replace the Third Marine Division near Da Nang.
Land faced a number of challenges. Like Bob Russel before him he was left to his own resources in acquiring equipment and personnel for his new sniper platoon.
“I had no guns, no instructors, I never had an office. But the one thing I did have was that I knew the location of just about every Distinguished Marksmen in Vietnam.” Distinguished Marksmen were top scoring marksmanship team competitors. One such marksman, who was assigned as a military policeman, was Carlos Norman Hathcock.
Of course, like Reacher, Swagger had to win the Wimbledon Cup because Hathcock did. Not the whole aggregate, just the Wimbledon. Apparently, it’s some sort of rite of passage for super macho tough guys.
Then there is the reality. Starting as a teenager, Michelle Gallagher has won the Wimbledon Cup five times. Her mother, Nancy, has won it as well. Not even fictional tough guys (never mind those in the real world) can make this claim.
http://www.womenshooters.com/archive/old1104issue/feature1104.html
Colorado Pete
Jan 16, 2014 @ 01:04:20
Just because some are “obsessed with guns” doesn’t mean they are obsessed with shooting. Seen plenty of friends and acquaintances pull things out of the safe and proudly show them off to me, then put them back until the next time they’re shown off. But go out and actually shoot them? Asking that will produce a deer-in-the-headlights look from many.
Owning guns is different from shooting guns.
LikeLike
John M. Buol Jr.
Jan 16, 2014 @ 11:02:05
>> Just because some are “obsessed with guns” doesn’t mean they are obsessed with shooting.
This is certainly the case!
My definition of a good gun owner is anyone capable of keeping and bearing arms without causing vandalism or undue injury to self or others.
https://firearmusernetwork.com/good-gun-owners/
Still, given 50-60 million gun owners, the vast majority of them good, I find it disheartening that such a small minority are interested in something beyond mere ownership.
LikeLike
Colorado Pete
Jan 16, 2014 @ 12:26:00
Pride of ownership pleases the ego.
Having to perform threatens the ego.
I think it’s that simple.
LikeLike
John M. Buol Jr.
Jan 16, 2014 @ 14:10:22
Once again, you’re spot on!
LikeLike
Vince Koers
Apr 25, 2016 @ 21:20:33
Tell me about this claim to be the “only civilian winner of the 1000 yard Wimbledon Cup… I have a picture of J.R. Buhmiller holding his trophy in 1937, and he was a railroader / rifle barrel builder, never in the military. Where can we find a list of winners over the years?
LikeLike
John M. Buol Jr.
Apr 26, 2016 @ 10:12:47
>> Tell me about this claim to be the “only civilian winner of the 1000 yard Wimbledon Cup
It is an incorrect claim made by Reacher/Child/Grant in a fictional story. Plenty of civilian shooters have won this over the years. Here’s a list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wimbledon_Cup#Trophy_Winners
LikeLike
Richard Cooper
Feb 20, 2018 @ 14:06:56
I was just reading a Reacher book and thought I would check out this fact. I love Lee Child’s books there is just so much info.
LikeLike